Singapore General Election 2011 – Aftermath

I’m not Singaporean, but I felt I was more excited about the recent election than many of my Singaporean friends. The result was never in doubt in my mind, PAP would win, leaving it to be a question of whether the opposition parties managed to get more than the one GRC the Workers Party (WP) was targeting. After all the votes were counted only the Aljunied GRC was won by the opposition, resulting in six WP representatives entering the parliament.

While many enthusiastic supporters of the opposition were looking for a huge success against the incumbent PAP, the majority (~60%) of Singaporeans still feel the PAP is the party to lead them into the future. Although I’m sure that many Singaporeans who did vote for the PAP also hoped that the opposition would win the Aljunied GRC.

This strange reasoning of voting for the PAP, but hoping for the opposition to win some seats is because many Singaporeans will tell you that this election was about sending a message of dissatisfaction about current PAP policies, an increasing level of arrogance and a disconnection from the lives of average Singaporeans. They wanted opposition members to win some seats to make sure that their voice was heard at the ballot box and during the next 5 years in parliament.

However, from an outsider’s perspective I feel that this election was about far more than that. This was an election about the awakening of Singaporeans to decide what type of Singapore they want for themselves and more importantly their children or grandchildren. It was a vote for a more transparent and open government, one that listens to its citizens and cares more for them, an end to dirty political tricks and a more balanced media. Essentially a freer, more open and democratic society that is inclusive of all citizens rather than being dominated by the elite few.

Apart from the obvious anger about the PAP’s performance this change was largely brought about with the engagement of the internet generation through the use of Youtube videos, Facebook, alternative news sites and personal blogs. This has turned many an apathetic Singaporean into a politically aware individual. I saw my Facebook news feed flooded with different points of view, mostly in favour of the opposition. There were also some amazing comments from people who were having a “hallelujah” moment as the censorship machine was thwarted by the internet and my friends finally saw the bias of the government controlled media. I personally can’t read the Straits Times because I find that I want to start yelling at the reporters for not doing their jobs!

The PAP now knows that Singaporeans will vote against them in large numbers, especially the internet generation, of which there will be many more at the next election. Whereas most SMCs and GRCs had a large majority in the past, requiring a massive swing to the opposition to ever be in doubt, quite a few seats would be in the opposition’s hands with less than a 10% swing in the next election.

What happens over the next 5 years will ultimately determine the pace of change in Singapore in the near future. I see a few scenarios:

  1. Lee Kuan Yew passes away and the PAP suffers a power struggle resulting in a split into two parties, creating the strongest opposition party in Singapore and possibly an immediate election.
  2. The PAP listens to the message that Singaporeans sent during the last general election and adopts appropriate policies to placate the anger. This will make it much harder for the opposition to make inroads in 2016, irrespective of their performance in Aljunied. Singaporeans do not like to rock the boat!
  3. The WP manages the Aljunied GRC effectively and gains respect of not only the local residents, but other Singaporeans who see that an opposition party can run a GRC well, giving them confidence to vote for the opposition. The opposition members of parliament perform well, attacking poor policies and providing the voice in parliament that Singaporeans want. The WP also manages to attract star talent and creates strong grassroots programs to build awareness and support across Singapore. Meanwhile the PAP does not address the concerns raised in 2011 and Singaporeans are even angrier in 2016. This results in a huge change in the parliament with a loss of the majority needed to pass legislation freely, or even a loss of power for the PAP.

Many people outside of Singapore would consider an election result that gave 81 of the 87 available seats to the incumbent party a huge defeat to the opposition. However, I believe that the 2011 general election will be remembered by many as the turning point in Singaporean politics, where the foundation of a strong opposition movement was laid. Thus defining a move towards a freer and more open society, together with the building of a modern Singaporean identity!

Singapore General Election 2011

Singaporean politics are definitely “Uniquely Singapore” with most elections a walk over for the ruling People’s Action Party (PAP), that has been in power since 1959, before Singapore’s independence. However, the 2011 election is starting to look very different with more opposition candidates than previous elections, contesting 82 out of the 87 seats. In fact, if it were not for some last minute delays from the opposition then all 87 seats would be contested. In the last election in 2006 only 47 out of 84 seats had opposition candidates. This means that many Singaporeans have never had their seat contested before and will now have to vote (it’s mandatory) for the first time in their life!

From a foreigner’s perspective this election is shaping up to be quite a bit more entertaining than the previous one. To be honest the last election was a forgone conclusion before voting even began. This time however, is different. Sure, the PAP will still win the election, but there could be a big shake up in the parliament with a number of opposition candidates likely to be voted in.

Singapore has an interesting concept of  Group Representation Constituencies (GRC), which groups a series of candidates together (up to 6), often with a very strong candidate that people respect together with weaker candidates that are new or have no track record. This allows people with practically no support to walk into parliament on the coat tails of the strong candidate. The voting is counted by party, not for an individual. It also makes it much more difficult for the opposition to contest a GRC as they have to put so many good candidates into one place. It seems the opposition is taking a gamble on Aljuneed GRC this time, even moving the leader of the Worker’s Party (WP) from his safe seat of Hougang to the Aljuneed GRC.

Based on what I’ve been reading online and from talking to Singaporean friends the general consensus is that they would like the opposition to win an GRC so that the government gets a strong message with the level of dissatisfaction of their recent performance, and that there are more opposition representatives in parliament to provide checks and balances to the ruling party.

If you were to take an opinion poll from the online community you would think that the opposition parties are about to sweep to power in Singapore and bring massive reforms. However, the reality is much more benign. There are still many PAP supporters, especially from the older generation, who believe in the party that has provided a solid set of policies to develop Singapore to the modern, safe, finance and manufacturing centre that it is today. Then there are the apathetic people who after so many walk over elections couldn’t care less about politics and will just vote the same party back into power so that they don’t have to worry about change.

What’s the difference this time that is making this election more interesting then you ask? It’s that the PAP seems to have lost its way. The politicians seem more arrogant than ever, appearing elite and out of touch with the average Singaporean. There is anger over the increasing cost of living in Singapore, the large number of “foreign talent” being brought into Singapore to help with the poor reproduction rate and to keep wages lower, and the lack of transparency of the government.

Another factor is the Internet and the government’s inability to control the dissemination of information as per with its total control of TV, newspapers, and radio. This means that the traditional media has had to open up its coverage of the opposition candidates and their policies to keep the public interested. Otherwise more and more Singaporeans will simply log on to the Internet and get uncensored information.

All in all I’m looking forward to this election and the slow, but sure change in Singapore’s political environment.

I Succumbed to Singtel mio TV!

I finally succumbed to getting Singtel mio TV installed, using the ADSL (Telephone) option and not the fibre that I wanted. After watching the first Forumla 1 race of the season at someone else’s place I decided that I couldn’t do that all year, especially when the Brazilian race is on at some ungodly hour!

I went into the Singtel centre at Parkway Parade and after a long wait got to speak to a guy there. I confirmed that I couldn’t get mio TV on fibre and signed up for the ADSL version with an 18 month contract at roughly $40 per month. The installation appointment was set for a 10-14 days later.

When the Singtel service guy came over I explained the issues with using the telephone line (bad locations of the points). He eventually gave up trying to get one working (which I told him was not connected) and ran a new line from outside my apartment into the existing conduit for my fibre and Starhub cable.

The second Singtel guy arrived to install the ADSL modem and the mio TV box. The ADSL modem is now sitting where the fibre was terminated in the living room. A network cable then runs around the side of the living room to my rack to connect to the mio TV box.

While not the solution that I wanted at least I can watch the EPL, Formula1 and the upcoming Rugby World Cup. I watched my first game of EPL at home this season on Monday night, Liverpool v Man City. Liverpool won convincingly 3-0, so I think it must be because I was watching! 😉